Archive | February, 2008

Peter Cadogan (1921-2007)

Peter Cadogan, who has died at 86, was once called ‘the most expelled socialist in England’. He campaigned effectively on many fronts for peace, justice and human rights in print, on the streets and through teams of like-minded thinkers.

He moved from radical politics [Labour, Communist, Workers Revolutionary and Socialist Worker Parties] to radical spirituality as he came to the conclusion that William Blake, Gandhi and John MacMurray were his greatest mentors for living a compassionate life. He died a happy man.

Peter Cadogan was born in Newcastle upon Tyne in 1921 where he witnessed the poverty and humiliation of workers during the Depression. The images of war veterans and unemployed miners begging on street corners stayed with him and drove him all his life.

After working briefly as an insurance clerk, he went on to serve in the Air Sea Rescue Service from 1941 to 1946. This proved to be a profound experience. Desperate attempts to save lives, during which he found authentic friendship with the men under his command, were separated by long periods of inactivity in which he read Shaw, Wells, John MacMurray, Laski and, most importantly, Lenin’s State and Revolution. He realised much later that this book “was a lethal confidence-trick”.

On demobilisation, he immediately joined the Communist Party to which he gave 10 devoted years, thrilling to the ideas buzzing around the Historian’s Group of the CP with Christopher Hill, E. P. Thompson, Eric Hobsbawm and others. In the meantime, he studied history at Newcastle University, married, had a daughter and moved to Northampton and then Cambridge to teach history in Secondary Modern schools. He is still remembered in both as an inspiring teacher.

In 1956, Khruschev’s demolition of Stalin came as a blow and, when the USSR invaded Hungary, his sharp criticisms of the CP found their way into the national press. He was suspended and then quit, quickly joining the Labour Party. Two years later, he organised for them the first nuclear base demonstration against the American Thor missiles at Mepal, near Ely.

He became a founder member of the Socialist Labour League which later became the Workers Revolutionary Party and was expelled by the Cambridge Labour Party. Other joinings and expulsions of factions on the Left followed.

In 1960, Bertrand Russell proposed non-violent civil disobedience against nuclear weapons. Cadogan joined his Committee of 100 and their campaign climaxed in September 1961 with a vast but banned demonstration in Trafalgar Square. Russell was arrested along with 1300 others. Early in 1962, Russell sent him and others to the World Peace Council in Moscow where they “staged a free, unlicensed demonstration in Red Square against all Bombs including those of the Soviet Union. The police moved in immediately. It was the first free demo in that Square since the 1920s and made world headlines”.

Within days of the Biafran War starting in May 1968, Cadogan had set up the Save Biafra Campaign and worked vigorously for 18 months getting a lot of national coverage. All to no avail as the Foreign Office “was stuck with the Lugard doctrine of ‘one Nigeria’ and the Wilson Government, as usual, did what it was told. London supplied Lagos with all its arms, ammunition and military advisers. Moscow provided its Air Force and trained its pilots – an unholy alliance to end all such alliances”. About a million innocent people died of starvation.

From 1970 to 1981, he was the General Secretary of the South Place Ethical Society at Conway Hall, known as London’s ‘temple of dissent’. He saw his main task there as defending ‘the rational religious sentiment’, each individual’s ‘sense of the sacred’, and to this end conducted over 50 weddings and funerals. In 1975, he wrote “Direct Democracy: An Appeal to the Professional Classes, to the Politically Disenchanted and to the Deprived. The Case for An England of Sovereign Regional Republics, Extra-Parliamentary Democracy and a New Active Non-Violence of the Centre”, modelling his title on The Levellers and integrating his “revelatory discovery” of William Blake and Friedrich Nietzsche. In it, he pioneered the idea of the gift economy.

This led to him co-founding the organisation and journal Turning Point with economist James Robertson which was published for over 25 years. From 1981 until his retirement in 1993, Peter was Tutor in the History of Ideas in the Extra-Mural Department of London University and the Workers Education Association.

By 1987 he had become disillusioned with all forms of protest and put his energies into what he called positive and practical solutions. From 1993, he worked for The Gandhi Foundation, leading their project in Northern Ireland and advocating Non-Violent Direct Action. He set up Values and Vision and Save London Alliance in his home on the base of his conviction that authentic national democracy can only emerge from local democracies. He became well-known in Kilburn for saving a local park, for Xmas lights on the High Road, his letters to the press and his garden. Local kids called him ‘Mr. Peter’.

During the 1990s he became the subject of great interest to historians, pre-eminent amongst them Professor Kevin Morgan, Professor of Politics and Contemporary History at Manchester University, who interviewed Peter in depth, placed the recordings in the National Sound Archives and anthologised his papers on the CP.

Peter continued to e-mail and write articles and letters to the very end. Throughout 65 years of radical activism, he was never afraid to speak his mind, to challenge and question his own and other people’s thinking. This seemed at first to many as intolerance, even arrogance. In fact, all soon discovered that it was no more than his passion for accuracy and clear thinking in the overall pursuit of justice.

Like Gandhi, he became and remained friends with all his temporary enemies. Over 70 people, old comrades and new friends, came to his bedside in St Mary’s Paddington or sent him messages of love and respect. Peter had co-founded The Blake Society in 1985, was its President for the first four years before becoming Life Vice-President. So it was appropriate that his last days fell during the month of Blake’s 250th anniversary. He quoted Blake’s poems to those around his bed and told us that Blake’s “Jerusalem” ‘said it all’. His dying words were Blake’s moral imperative “Live differently”! Peter did just that, his integrity intact.
John Rowley

Instead of ending his copious and challenging notes, letters and writings “with all good wishes” or something, Peter would say “oxygen, peace, flowers”. I loved that ending: oxygen for the life we breathe in and out; peace, we all yearn for whether secretly or openly; flowers, symbolising nature which surrounds and nourishes. Peter first introduced me to the Northern Ireland Working Group in London which he and I represented within the GF. In the 1980s, we joined a group to visit Dublin to discover more about “the Troubles” from across the border. He was indefatigable in his work and writings, giving great support to those he believed had “got it right” in Northern Ireland. He was a warrior of the right kind and he leaves a gap behind him. Go ye well, Peter. It was rich knowing you.
Denise Moll

Pingalwara – by Chris Clarke

By anyone’s standards, even the lofty ones of The Gandhi Foundation, Amritsar is a holy city. As well as the Golden Temple, there are dozens of gurdwaras, mosques, and mandirs, as many as there are pubs in an English city. But for me, one of the holiest places in the world is another building in Amritsar, one you will not have heard of. Just a short ginrickshaw ride from the Golden Temple, past Jallianwala Bagh, opposite the bus stand in a dusty bazaar selling tyres, bananas, and cocacola (as all bazaars in India do), is Pingalwara, literally House of Cripples.

As the name implies, the residents of Pingalwara are Amritsar’s destitute – orphans, the elderly, homeless, physically and mentally disabled – and as the name also implies, they are neither shy nor embarrassed about what they do there. Pingalwara is an astonishing achievement. They house over 1200 residents in six cities. They run hospital services, dentistry, homes for those who need them, prosthetics centres, dispensaries, rehabilitation units, schools, a printing press, an animal sanctuary and a tree nursery, all through charitable contributions. But Pingalwara is all the more astonishing when you know the story of how it came about.

As good Gandhians, you will know that at the start of the twentieth century, India was still run by white men in shorts and pith helmets, who shot tigers and drank gin in the heat. Kipling was writing stirring tales of bravery on the North West frontier, and India had no thought of independence beyond a rumour of some lawyer disturbing the peace in South Africa. Into the Punjab, in 1904, was born Ramji Das, to a widow who was befriended by Ramji’s father, a wealthy businessman who kept the boy at a distance for fear of disturbing the inheritance arrangements.

Ramji was sent to boarding school first in Khanna and later in Lahore. In his spare time he served in the Hindu temples, cleared litter and stones from the street, and was kind to animals; unusual, for one of his years. Eventually the family finances dried up and the boy ended up homeless, a hundred miles from his family. Sadly, even the mandirs where he served refused him help.

Fortunately the Punjab is predominantly Sikh, and with the help of some local farmers he found his way to a Sikh temple. Everyone who comes to a Gurdwara, anyone at all, is welcomed, fed, offered shelter and the opportunity to hear from the Guru Granth Sahib. I shall never forget my first visit to a Gurdwara. It was a haven from the New Delhi taxi drivers who have replaced the “jungle, tigers, cobras, cholera, and sepoys” that beset the European travelers of Kipling’s time and who, trust me, are far more frightening. And the kindness of the Sikhs was overwhelming.

The penniless, starving, and homeless boy of our story records that he too was conquered by their kindness. He converted to Sikhism, and changed his name to Puran Singh. Christians and Sikhs both believe that we get to heaven only by God’s Grace, not by our own efforts. But the more astute of us will have noticed how opportunities to show our appreciation often make themselves apparent. So it was that Puran Singh passed by a little boy at the entrance to Gurdwara Dehra Sahib, abandoned, and clearly mentally and physically disabled. To be an orphan in India is bad enough, even today. To be so profoundly disabled is practically a death sentence. So Puran Singh did what had to be done. He picked up the boy, cleaned away the excrement from his body and clothes, fed him, and gave him a name – Piara, which means “beloved”.

Now Piara had no family, Puran Singh had no wheelchair and so took to carrying Piara who clung to Puran “like a garland around my neck”, he said. Piara had found a family, and Puran had found a way of serving God. For the next thirty years, Puran Singh worked full time in all sorts of charitable causes, until partition intervened. When hell finally broke loose on 13 August 1947, Puran Singh was out working, and had left Piara at the Gurdwara. By the time Puran Singh heard the riots and returned, rioters had surrounded the place, and Piara was alone and vulnerable in the middle of it. Somehow Piara was rescued and the pair managed to escape Lahore, and on the 18th August the pair reached the Indian side of the Punjab, where matters were not much better.

Puran Singh

Puran Singh and Piara

Partition displaced millions, the Punjab was rent open and Amritsar, its beating heart, was exposed to all the human sufferings it is possible to see. The well-appointed gardens of Khalsa College were turned over to the twenty-five thousand refugees flooding in along the Grand Trunk Road day by humid August day.

No human being runs a Sikh temple. God does. To be more precise, the spirit of the Sikh gurus resides in the holy book, the Guru Granth Sahib, which is read aloud to provide guidance to those who would listen. Now, the practicalities of this arrangement are simple: it is down to everyone to get on and cook, clean, read and serve, so that no-one who visits guruji ever goes away hungry, thirsty, tired, or unloved. By this fine example are all Sikhs taught, and Puran Singh learned the lesson well. So with only the clothes he stood up in, he set about caring for the refugees at Khalsa College.

Months and years went by, and eventually the shanty towns disappeared. Only Puran Singh and his ragged collection of destitutes remained. By this time he was dressed as a tramp, hair unkempt and unturbaned, begging from door to door for the money to feed his family, living and dressing beneath the lowest dalit on the dirtiest city street in India. The arches at Amritsar railway station became home for a while, and the move to this better accommodation was accompanied by increasing donations. Eventually a plot of land became free and with a donation from the Golden Temple Committee, Pingalwara was finally completed on 6th March 1957.

As a young man, Puran Singh discovered Gandhiji, took to wearing khaddar and read all he could about Bapu. Puran shared Bapu’s ideas about village life and sustainability and took a keen interest in the environment. Perhaps because Pingalwara is so close to a heavily polluted part of Amritsar, or because he saw so many people die of respiratory problems, in his later years he often berated dignitaries who turned up to Pingalwara in motorised transport. As far back as 1928, he was aware of the dangers of flooding caused by deforestation, and he had passing connections with Mirabehn and Sarlabehn (Katherine Heilemann, another of Gandhi’s European followers). Sunder Lal Bahuguna – one of the founders of the Chipko movement and another Gandhian – is a patron of Pingalwara.

Like Bapu, when Puran Singh died his possessions amounted to just a pile of clothes, a pair of spectacles, and the few tools needed in his daily routine. After Puran Singh died in 1992 Bibi Inderjit Kaur, a physician and disciple of Bhagatji, took over the running of Pingalwara, a post she still holds today.

Pingalwara is open to visitors. In fact they are welcomed. Puran Singh’s original campus on the Grand Trunk Road is still a peaceful oasis amid the noise and squalor of India’s first road. Most visitors to Amritsar only want to see the Golden Temple and the Wagah border closing ceremony before they move on to Dharamsala. But the Punjab is full of modest little gems, and Pingalwara is among the best of them.

I feel I ought to leave you with some of Bhagatji’s favourite advice. These points are repeated in all of Pingalwara’s publications. It has been said that Gandhi’s standards are for most people impossibly high. If that is so, then Puran Singh’s advice is a practical and gentle introduction that will not send you far wrong:

Preserve natural resources
Service of the poor and destitute is the service of God
Plant more and more trees to save the environment
Wear khadi clothes to lessen unemployment
Simple living and high thinking is a bliss
Use less diesel and petrol
Exercise restraint in your living habits

Don’t forget to plant trees. They are a sign of the prosperity of a nation!

The Pingalwara website is, where you can find details of how to visit, volunteer or donate to them.


Garland around my neck: The story of Puran Singh of Pingalwara by Patwant Singh,
UBSPD, 2001, ISBN 978-8174763372, contains many good pictures.

His Sacred Burden: The Life of Bhagat Puran Singh by Reema Anand, Penguin
Books, 2004 is a more detailed biography.

Chris Clarke is active in the interfaith movement in Newcastle. Brought up an Anglican he now serves at the local gurdwara and Hindu temple.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 878 other followers